Understanding Homeowners Property Claims in Colorado

About the Author: Dan Ballard

What Every Homeowner Should Know Before Filing a Claim

Colorado’s weather has always been tough on homes. Between hailstorms, high winds, and sudden seasonal shifts, exterior damage is something most homeowners will deal with at some point.

What’s changed over the years isn’t the weather—it’s how insurance policies respond to it. And if you haven’t reviewed your coverage recently, there’s a good chance it doesn’t work the way you think it does.

Why Insurance Coverage Has Changed in Colorado

Colorado is considered one of the highest-risk states in the country for hail damage. As claim frequency and costs have increased, insurance carriers have adjusted accordingly.

  • Higher premiums

  • Deductibles based on a percentage of home value

  • More limitations on roof coverage

Homeowners today are seeing:

Then vs. Now: What Homeowners Need to Understand

Two or three decades ago, most policies carried low deductibles, often under $1,000. When storm damage occurred, the process of replacing a roof was relatively simple.

That same period also saw the rise of “free roof” marketing, where contractors would waive deductibles. That practice was illegal then and remains illegal today.

As Colorado’s roofing market expanded, so did competition—and in some cases, aggressive or misleading sales tactics. Those practices have played a role in shaping today’s insurance environment.

Contingency Contracts and Storm Chasing

After a major storm, it’s common for contractors to go door-to-door offering inspections. Many homeowners are asked to sign contingency agreements early in the process.

  • Signing before receiving a detailed estimate
  • Being locked into a contract if insurance approves the claim

  • Limited ability to compare contractors

From an insurance standpoint, this is often where claims begin to escalate beyond what’s necessary.

The Bigger Impact on Homeowners

When claims are consistently pushed toward full replacement, it affects more than just one property. It contributes to broader changes across the insurance market.

That’s why many homeowners are now seeing:

  • Reduced eligibility for full replacement coverage

  • Higher out-of-pocket costs

  • A shift toward Actual Cash Value (ACV) policies

The Campbell Roofing, Inc. Difference

Campbell Roofing, Inc. has been serving Colorado homeowners since 1984. As a family-owned and operated company, we’ve built our reputation over decades—not storm seasons.

We are also proud to be a preferred contractor for USAA for more than 25 years, a distinction that reflects consistent quality, reliability, and trust.

Our approach is straightforward:

  • Thorough, honest inspections

  • Clear, detailed estimates—no contingency contracts

  • Guidance based on real insurance experience

  • Work that meets both homeowner expectations and carrier standards

With a background in insurance adjusting, we understand how claims are evaluated—and how to keep the process accurate, fair, and efficient.

Final Thoughts

Storm damage is part of living in Colorado, but confusion around insurance claims doesn’t have to be.

Taking the time to understand your policy—and working with a contractor who values accuracy over sales—can make a significant difference in both outcome and cost.

If you believe your home has been affected by a recent storm, start with a professional inspection and make an informed decision from there.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

No. The decision to file a claim is always yours. A professional contractor should provide enough information for you to make that decision—not pressure you into it.

A contingency contract becomes binding if your insurance claim is approved. While common, it can limit your ability to compare options. It’s important to fully understand the terms before signing anything.

Because Colorado sees a high volume of these claims, insurance carriers often use percentage-based deductibles to offset risk.

Replacement Cost covers the full cost to replace your roof (minus deductible), while ACV factors in depreciation, reducing the payout based on age and condition.

No. Waiving or covering deductibles is illegal and can put both the homeowner and contractor at risk.

Only if the damage justifies it under the terms of your policy. Not all damage requires full replacement—some situations call for repair.

Only if the damage justifies it under the terms of your policy. Not all damage requires full replacement—some situations call for repair.

The best way is to have it professionally inspected. Many signs of damage aren’t visible from the ground or to an untrained eye.

Related Articles

Go to Top